Geeks + Gamers › Forums › Entertainment › Music › Hard Rock is allowed to cover your song, but not the other way around
No, just no.
You turned an emotional song based on anger/lashing out, filled with energy and you sucked the life out of it and made it a whiny ballad fit for a 90’s goth kid trying to get his parents attention. (Yes, the argument could probably be made that was what the original song was but the original song busted down your door, ran into the room and punched you in the face. This version knocks politely, asks to come in and curtseys when it meets you).
Stop that. Don’t do it again.
It’s even worse when the original song was a ballad and they try to “jazz it up” by making it a dance hit, making it loose all meaning in the progress despite me liking EDM and Trance (although that’s usually the late 90’s, early 2000’s stuff). In some cases it’s not too bad but maybe that’s because I usually hate ballads in general unless they’re sung really well. A lot of modern dance music I’m hearing now seems to be covering what was originally 90’s ballads. I remember a while back hearing some dance remix of ‘I Want It That Way’ (originally by the Backstreet Boys) and as a fan of the Backstreet Boys, I had to switch my radio off for a couple of minutes because the dance remixed version was just horrible.
An ABBA cover by a pair of young Irish girls that sounds pretty good.
Would be disco to rock, or disco to funk.
I usually prefer it when pop goes classical. Some of the classical versions are a dozen times better than the originals, even if I like the original version.
L’Orchestra Cinématique usually does some really good “Epic” versions of stuff. They did a 90’s theme a few years ago. Was a bit sad that they never covered the Spice Girls (would’ve loved to have heard a epic version of ‘Spice Up Your Life’) but at least they did the Backstreet Boys and a few other artists at the time.
I do not at all disagree with y’alls choices. I know music is a personal choice and I often hear things that are not my style but that I can still appreciate.
But with that said.
THIS is how you covers songs ;)
Believe it or not, I saw Papa Roach before they were signed. They played in an empty quad on a campus during Summer School, and I have to tell you that they deserve all the success they achieved. I’m not a fan of them, but the performance was incredible. So much energy and they were really athletic at the time and I was one of the only people in the crowd. You would have thought they were playing for tens of thousands of people. They totally rocked it. The lead singer was aggressive as hell and really funny and entertaining. My brief interaction with them was positive and they are good guys.
To turn Last Resort into an Emo song is funny asf tho.
I’m a bit upset that Draiman from Disturbed is most known for this cover song. It’s good and all but I actually like Disturbed for the unique style they brought to Nu Metal. I don’t agree with his politics, but the guy has real talent. His has like a staccato vocal riff style. He has my respect. He has a signature sound. Obviously, Indestructible is just an awesome song. I also like one called The Night.
And regarding Sounds of Silence, here is another cover of Simon and Garfunkel.
Another one I usually follow is Postmodern Jukebox which does vintage style covers of modern pop songs. Loved their Andrews Sisters style version of ‘Wannabe’😍 and a Chicago-style inspired version of ‘Single Ladies’.
Well you just aged yourself :P
But that is cool as hell man! Awesome story. I have always heard they were good guys.
Disturbed is amazing. Draiman is know for that cover because of insanely well they did it. There is a live performance he did on Conan O’Brien’s show that is better than the official video even. Amazing!
Ok, so I am not just a hard rock guy. I can appreciate other stuff too. Here is one of my favorite off the beaten path guys. :)
Yeah, I am past the expiration date. My sister took me to the Backstreet Boys and they were great live. Boy bands are positive music. I’ve always been into that retro and vintage and classic type style, so I do like that music. In fact, one of my favorite bands was Big Bad Voodoo Daddy because of all the swing dancers. I actually was a bit resentful that I didn’t grow up knowing Swing, 2-step and salsa. That is the kind of thing that Hollywood kind of got right is, every now and then, they just had so much style and class and that appealed to me and I perceive that as real culture.
Draiman is the man.
Regarding Separate Ways by Journey, I did like that Daughtry version. A former guitarist for Journey took the lick and riff and made a gospel song of it. He left the rock scene because he said that the secular worship energy of the rock crowd corrupted and destroyed to many of his fellow musicians. Anyway, I actually think this song would fall into the category of No, but I’ll post it anyway. Rock to gospel, which is interesting because a lot of rock actually came from gospel.
I’m always impressed by the artists who can play and sing. Losing the feeling though. Always wondered if there would be another Joni Mitchell. Nope.
Another Simon and Garfunkel song. Cray how influential Paul Simon was. So many good songs. I didn’t really grow up with his music and I like retro and past stuff so much that I never related to my peers. My classmates had no idea who the bands I liked were. Scratching my head and Paul Simon though. An under the radar hit maker.
Given what you just said I am going to suggest a movie to you I watch every so often. Why? It’s about salsa dancing, it’s funny, feel good and there is no BS in it.
Also I am linking a video I am curious if you have seen and what you think about it. My sister loved all the boys bands in the 80s/90s. I never cared for them but I saw this recently and my hats off to them.
Legendary.
This version really…touched me.
The ironic part there is, if you closely listen to the original Simon and Garfunkel song it sounds like they are discussing authoritarian censorship. I believe it’s actually about technology but those 2 things are now nearly synonymous.
Very astute observation. Was thinking along those lines, too. People talking without speaking, to me, was telepathy or neuralink. I read about the meaning of the song and they blew it off for the emotionally lonely people who cannot connect with anyone and that makes a ton of sense, but like all good art, it can be interpreted in many ways and that is the trick of using ambiguous and vague language is that the listener fills in the gaps with their own ideas.
And the people bowed and prayed
To the neon god they made
This line was considered blasphemous.
Seeing how many things have changed, you are really onto something in terms of Cancel Culture and Big Tech censorship, it’s like, you can talk all you want, but freedom of speech is not freedom of reach. Also, I could see it as a song about communism because I heard is some countries, 2 people could talk, but 3 or more was forbidden by authorities, and after the lockdown, you can see how people are conditioned.
Im probobly gonna be in the minority here, but i think you just chalk this one up to “interpretation”.
In regards to the first song….i always did like Ronnie Radke.
Same great song just seen thru a different set of glasses.